Originally posted by J.A. Veil
View Post
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Native introduces new Slayer Propel 12.5 Max
Collapse
X
-
I have yet to try a pedal yak. Which system does anyone with experience prefer...hobie/fins or Native/prop? I was set on a Propel but watching some Hobie vids, the leg motion seems like it might be preferable?
Also, going to be snakeheading, so I'll be in a lot of shallows/grassy/pads areas. Hobie fins better for that?Native Slayer 12
Native Ultimate
Comment
-
An advantage to the Hobie fins over propeller driven pedal boats is that you can "feather" them by pushing the pedals all the way forward so that they align near the hull of the boat and do not fully extend into the water. Even in that position they will move the boat, just not as fast. In skinny water with propeller drives you may have to pull the drive mechanism from the water to avoid hitting bottom.
However, in thick vegetation the Hobie fins will foul even if aligned near the hull. That is why I do not use my Hobie in ponds or tidal areas thick with plant growth.
I do use my Hobie in shallow tidal water with the feathering technique I described above. In fact, one reason I do not have the longer Hobie Turbo fins is because I fish so much in shallow water. The extra length of the Turbo fins would be problematic to me in the areas I like to fish. The other reason is that I have a Revo 13 which is a sleek fast boat that moves just fine with the regular fins in my opinion.
As to the in-and-out pedaling motion of the Hobie, versus the bicycle pedaling motion of propeller driven kayaks, you'll have to test for yourself. I do not mind the in-and-out motion of the pedals. With the cadence of an easy stroll down a sidewalk I can maintain 3 mph in the Hobie for a long time without rest. I can sprint up to 6 mph -- but not for long.
With the bicycle motion, going in reverse is easier. You simply pedal backwards. I have the Mirage 180 and I have to shift into reverse by pulling a lever. That's no big deal for me now. I do it without thinking about it.
I have no experience with the new Mirage 360 drives.
And that's another thing to keep in mind. Sometimes you can overthink a purchase. You will acclimate to which ever drive system you purchase unless physical ailments in your knees or back prevents you from using one system over the other.
But overall, I have been very pleased with the ease of using the Hobie system, its performance and its reliability.
Good luck in your purchase.Mark
Pasadena, MD
Slate Hobie Revolution 13
Hidden Oak Native Ultimate 12
Lizard Lick Native Ultimate FX Pro
Comment
-
Originally posted by gliebig View PostI have yet to try a pedal yak. Which system does anyone with experience prefer...hobie/fins or Native/prop? I was set on a Propel but watching some Hobie vids, the leg motion seems like it might be preferable?
Also, going to be snakeheading, so I'll be in a lot of shallows/grassy/pads areas. Hobie fins better for that?
I encourage you to take advantage of demo days offered by dealers in the spring and try out both systems. In addition to the pedal drive system, evaluate the other parts of the kayak that are important to you (e.g., seat comfort, storage, gear tracks).John Veil
Annapolis
Native Watercraft Manta Ray 11, Falcon 11
Author - "Fishing in the Comfort Zone" , "Fishing Road Trip - 2019", "My Fishing Life: Two Years to Remember", and "The Way I Like to Fish -- A Kayak Angler's Guide to Shallow Water, Light Tackle Fishing"
Comment
-
Originally posted by J.A. Veil View PostI understand why you are asking this question, but given the makeup of Snaggedline members, far more fish from Hobies than from the brands with a propeller drive (it may be as much as 10:1 in favor of Hobie). I suspect that you may get a skewed opinion. I have used both and see the advantage of the Hobie for shallow water usage, but really like the instant reverse on the Natives. The Native Propel drives can be pivoted up from the hull in less than 10 seconds without any heavy lifting when you get into shallow water.
I encourage you to take advantage of demo days offered by dealers in the spring and try out both systems. In addition to the pedal drive system, evaluate the other parts of the kayak that are important to you (e.g., seat comfort, storage, gear tracks).
I like everything about the Titan 10.5...size...price...Stability for standing..
I plan on fishing the susky flats/blackwater a good bit this year. Both areas have some thick vegetation. Does the propel drive do okay with that? I know any prop system will gather weeds, I just don't want something that is overly frustrating by having to clear it to frequently.Native Slayer 12
Native Ultimate
Comment
-
Originally posted by gliebig View PostI will try and get on a demo. Wish there were dealers a bit closer.
https://www.delawarepaddlesports.com/2019-demo-days/
Or folks on this forum may offer you an opportunity to pedal their boats. You're welcome to try my Revo at a mutually agreeable time and place this spring.
For what it's worth, I took my former Revo to Mattawoman one time. Not only did the drive choke with weeds so did the rudder. I was not pedaling in visible surface vegetation either. The good news is that I could lock the fins to the hull and raise the rudder and continue fishing with paddle power. However, that experience is one reason I have two paddle kayaks. So I can fish areas like this:
P1040596 (3).jpgMark
Pasadena, MD
Slate Hobie Revolution 13
Hidden Oak Native Ultimate 12
Lizard Lick Native Ultimate FX Pro
Comment
-
Originally posted by Mark View PostDelaware Paddlesports has 3 demo days planned in April, May and June. It's worth the drive.
https://www.delawarepaddlesports.com/2019-demo-days/
Or folks on this forum may offer you an opportunity to pedal their boats. You're welcome to try my Revo at a mutually agreeable time and place this spring.
For what it's worth, I took my former Revo to Mattawoman one time. Not only did the drive choke with weeds so did the rudder. I was not pedaling in visible surface vegetation either. The good news is that I could lock the fins to the hull and raise the rudder and continue fishing with paddle power. However, that experience is one reason I have two paddle kayaks. So I can fish areas like this:
[ATTACH=CONFIG]25963[/ATTACH]Native Slayer 12
Native Ultimate
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by gliebig View PostI will try and get on a demo. Wish there were dealers a bit closer.
I like everything about the Titan 10.5...size...price...Stability for standing..
I plan on fishing the susky flats/blackwater a good bit this year. Both areas have some thick vegetation. Does the propel drive do okay with that? I know any prop system will gather weeds, I just don't want something that is overly frustrating by having to clear it to frequently.John Veil
Annapolis
Native Watercraft Manta Ray 11, Falcon 11
Author - "Fishing in the Comfort Zone" , "Fishing Road Trip - 2019", "My Fishing Life: Two Years to Remember", and "The Way I Like to Fish -- A Kayak Angler's Guide to Shallow Water, Light Tackle Fishing"
Comment
-
Originally posted by gliebig View PostI have yet to try a pedal yak. Which system does anyone with experience prefer...hobie/fins or Native/prop? I was set on a Propel but watching some Hobie vids, the leg motion seems like it might be preferable?
Also, going to be snakeheading, so I'll be in a lot of shallows/grassy/pads areas. Hobie fins better for that?
My next yak might be a Native since they have the instant reverse which would be immensely helpful when holding over a particular spot. In my case, the 2014 GT drive (not a MD-180/360) means I'm constantly circling or have to put down an anchor. But the upside is that the fins rarely foul up, unless I'm bushwhacking across heavy vegetation--and even then it's easy to lift the drive out, clean off the salad, and drop it back in.I need a good paddling
Motorized 2014 Hobie Pro Angler 12
Garmin Echomap 93sv
RIP, favorite St. Croix Rod
Comment
Comment